AWRA OpsHub Search

Three Quotes and No Way to Score Them

We have requests for quotation, with real line items, sent to real suppliers, with responses recorded and comparable — and sealed until a recorded opening when the round calls for it. We have no request for proposal, no request for information, no scoring model of your own and no panel. Those are not degrees of the same thing.

Procurement Insights AWRA OpsHub Team 11 min read

A request for quotation asks a supplier one question: what will you charge for this exact thing? A request for proposal asks a much harder one: how would you solve this, and why should it be you? Our product does the first properly and does not attempt the second.

That distinction is not about rigour or maturity. It is about what is being compared. And it decides whether this product belongs anywhere near your sourcing process.

What we have

A request for quotation with relational line items — real rows with an item and a quantity — sent to selected suppliers, with responses recorded against it. A comparison across the responses on price, delivery time and a rating, with weights that must sum to one. A persisted ranking and a best-quote status. And, when the round needs it, a sealed request: a deadline after which quotes are refused, prices hidden from every buyer until the bids are opened, an opening that can only happen after the deadline and is recorded with who and when, and no award before it.

For a defined basket of known goods, that is the right tool and it works. You are asking several suppliers for a number against the same list, and a number against a list is exactly what a quotation is.

What an RFP needs, and how much of it is here

Four things. Three of them are absences of different kinds; the fourth, and the one that matters most, we built.

  • A non-price submission. A proposal is a document — a method, a team, references, a timeline. There is nowhere to receive one and nothing to compare it with, because a comparison across proposals is a comparison across prose.
  • Criteria with weights that are not price, delivery and a rating. Technical capability, experience, local content, capacity, warranty. Our three factors are fixed; you cannot define a fourth.
  • More than one evaluator. A panel scores independently and the scores are combined. Here there is one comparison, run by one person, with weights they chose at the time.
  • Sealed bids. Submissions that cannot be seen until a stated opening. This one we have: a sealed request hides every quoted price from the buying side until the bids are opened after the deadline, records the opening, and refuses an award before it.

The fourth one is the load-bearing requirement. Everything else on that list can be done in a spreadsheet honestly. Sealing cannot — which is why it is the one we built.

That is worth dwelling on. A panel can score on paper and total the results by hand — laborious, and the outcome is as sound as the people. But the integrity of a competitive process rests on nobody having seen the numbers before the opening, and that is a property of the system holding them, not of the people using it. You cannot restore it procedurally after the fact.

Why a Tanzanian buyer runs into this specifically

Because the sourcing landscape here has a strong institutional layer running alongside ordinary commercial buying, and organisations move between the two constantly. A distributor supplying private customers on ordinary terms may also bid into, or run, processes with formal competitive requirements — public bodies, parastatals, large institutional buyers, donor-funded programmes.

The trap is that both look like "getting three quotes" from a distance. They are different obligations. One needs a comparable number; the other needs a defensible process, and a defensible process is mostly about what nobody could see and when.

What you are running What it needs Supported here?
Routine competitive purchasing Several quotes on one basket, compared Yes
A framework or standing offer Terms agreed once, drawn down against Yes — a supplier contract with an agreed price list, drawn down by call-off
A technical evaluation Non-price criteria with weights No
A panel evaluation Independent scores, combined No
A sealed tender Concealment until an opening Yes — a sealed request, opened after its deadline, with the opening recorded
An audit trail of who decided what Recorded approvals with actor and time Yes, on the approval chain

The last row matters. What this product does give a formal process is the half that comes after the decision: an approval chain with named actors and timestamps, an order that cannot be raised without an approved request, and a payment that cannot be released against a discrepant delivery. Those are real and they are worth having. They just do not evaluate anything.

Scope, not a ceiling

What a tender module would actually need

We would rather set out the shape than imply this is a small extension of the quotation screen. It is not — it is a different document with a different lifecycle. The sealing it would rest on is already built; what remains is the document, the criteria and the panel.

Clarification questions and revision rounds

Questions from bidders answered once and shared with all of them, and a best-and-final round on the shortlist, both recorded against the tender.

Definable criteria with weights

Non-price criteria set per tender rather than the fixed three. Mechanically straightforward once the document exists.

Panel scoring with independent scores

Each evaluator scores without seeing the others, and the combination is recorded. The audit trail here is the deliverable, not the arithmetic.

We put scope on a public page and dates in a written quote. If you run formal competitive processes as a routine part of your operation, describe them and we will come back with a written scope, timeline and cost — including an honest view of whether a specialist tender platform is the better answer.

Scope a tender process

The sourcing ledger, precisely

What AWRA OpsHub does today

  • Requests for quotation with relational line items, issued to selected suppliers, with responses recorded against the request.
  • A weighted comparison across responses on price, distance, delivery time and each supplier's stored track record, with a persisted ranking.
  • Supplier prequalification as a public application, review and approval workflow, with qualification expiry that deactivates a lapsed supplier automatically.
  • Blacklisting with a recorded reason and actor, and a refusal of re-application from the same email.
  • An approval chain with named actors and timestamps, and a refusal to raise an order against an unapproved request.
  • Sealed requests for quotation: a deadline after which late quotes are refused, prices hidden from the buying side until a recorded opening after the deadline, and no award before it.
  • Supplier contracts with an agreed price list, dates and a value ceiling, drawn down by call-offs that go through the normal approval to an order.

More we can add to your workspace

  • A request-for-proposal or request-for-information entity. Only requests for quotation exist. Commission it
  • Definable evaluation criteria. The comparison factors are fixed at price, delivery time and a rating field nothing populates. Commission it
  • Panel or multi-evaluator scoring of any kind. Commission it
  • Clarification questions and answers shared with every bidder, and revision rounds (best and final offer). Commission it

Where we point you to a specialist

  • Technical and panel evaluation happens outside this product today, and we would rather say so than let a quotation comparison be mistaken for an evaluation.
  • The controls around the decision — approval, matching, the payment gate — are real and do apply to a formally sourced purchase once the decision is made.
  • This is market-neutral. It is the difference between a quotation and a proposal; this is a market where one organisation routinely does both.

Our position

Use this for competitive quotations on defined baskets, which is most purchasing. Sealed quotation rounds run here, with a deadline and a recorded opening. Run proposal-based tenders with panel scoring elsewhere and bring the award back in as a requisition and an order, so the controls and the audit trail after the decision still apply. If panel-scored proposals are a regular obligation rather than an occasional one, a specialist platform is probably the honest answer and we will say so on a call.

Four questions to separate a quotation tool from a tender platform

Can a submission be concealed until an opening date?

A good answer sounds like

Yes, with a recorded opening.

What it actually means

The one requirement that cannot be met by careful people using a simpler tool. Ask it first.

Can I define my own evaluation criteria?

A good answer sounds like

Yes, per tender, with weights.

What it actually means

Fixed criteria mean the tool decides what matters, which is the wrong way round for anything technical.

Can three people score independently?

A good answer sounds like

Yes, without seeing each other.

What it actually means

A shared spreadsheet is not independent scoring, and neither is one person entering everybody's marks.

Where does a supplier upload a proposal document?

A good answer sounds like

A portal, against the tender.

What it actually means

Email attachments are the default answer and they are also the reason nobody can reconstruct what was submitted.

Work out which of your processes are which

Most organisations run both kinds and treat them as one. Separating them is an afternoon's work and it tells you exactly which parts of your sourcing this product can carry.

Sort the processes

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a request for quotation as a tender?

You can use it to collect prices, and it will do that well. Seal it and it also gives you concealment until an opening after the deadline, recorded with who opened it and when. What it will not give you is criteria you defined or independent scores from more than one person — so for a price-only tender it holds up, and for a technical one the evaluation still happens elsewhere.

What should I bring back into the system after an external tender?

The award, as a requisition and then an order against the winning supplier, with the evaluation attached as a document. That way the approval chain, the receipt matching and the payment gate all apply to the purchase even though the evaluation happened elsewhere.

Do you have framework agreements?

Yes. A supplier contract holds the agreed price list, the start and end dates and a value ceiling. A call-off against it creates a quotation at the contract prices that goes through the normal approval to an order, a quote above the contract price is flagged, and contracts expire on their end date automatically.

Share this article

LinkedIn X WhatsApp

Help Center

Need a quick answer while you read?

Run inventory, procurement, assets, sales, and field work with approved AWRA guidance for setup, migration, integrations, security, pricing, and support.

Search all approved AWRA public help articles.

Open Help Center